Cartoon Kangaroo Disco
People are going back and forth across the doorsill where the two worlds touch. The door is round and open. Don't go back to sleep. -Rumi
Mid-October.
A river of psychedelic pink begins floating through the feeds of everyone’s phones; I hear it described before I look for myself. Something about have you seen the sky, no no, it’s in New York, it’s in fucking Westchester! I am at a beloved friend’s birthday dinner in Greenpoint, and all of my energy is focused on attempting to have actual conversations with actual people, people I care deeply about but have mostly not seen, many for years, some since before the…well, you know,
BEFORE.
News of the sky is a murmur, therefore, relegated to a background din, swallowed by kid catchups, Kamala-casting, and weird new middle-age malady comparisons. To say my social muscles have atrophied in recent years is an understatement. I’m reminded that night, though, it isn’t just me. There is a franticness in speech. Sustained eye contact seems straining. All of it is very loud. How it seems is, of course, entirely dependent on my particular lens, which necessarily includes an extreme sensitivity to the most remote stimuli, and a bunch of excited humans who love each other in an intimate space means a kind of overwhelm — documentable through Apple’s recording of my heart-rate that night — to my always hyper-attuned nervous system…
—
Last February.
Wooly Mammoths begin running wild on Facebook, clopping along through a landscape of blowing snow; Cherry blossoms whoosh by, drone-like, as a couple walks along what appears to be Tokyo’s wintery streets. Hybrid mini-monsters watch woefully while a candle ominously collapses into itself. None of it exists, not in reality. Around this time is when I was diagnosed with what the psychiatric literature commonly refers to as the BTMFC.
The Big-Time Motherfucking Creeps.
OpenAI, the same company behind ChatGPT and the still-image generator DALL-E, presented us a sample of their text-to-video artificial intelligence. The team behind the technology called it Sora, after the Japanese word for sky, saying in an interview they chose this name because it “evokes the idea of limitless creative potential.”
They are still working to understand the system’s dangers, they also said.
For years.
The amount of downward-facing dead-eyedness we’re doing as a species disturbs me. I mean, it disturbs me a lot. I’m probably extrapolating to the whole species because I’m terrified of how much I do it myself. But it is almost all of us most of the time, right? Just by observation, on any given elevator or subway ride, in line at the grocery store, waiting for anyone or anything anywhere to arrive. Why wait or wonder when you can scroll? There’s a cartoon showing the stages of man, how we dragged ourselves out of the mire into hunched-over ape-itude and finally figured out tools, enough to eventually become upright, only to be tech-necking our way back down into a morass of our own making.
What we spend most of our time looking at now is unnatural. A six-inch hunk of robots holds the vast majority of our gaze, which means the 16 billion or so transistors that control our attention sit in between us and our given home. This frenzied pitch about the rise of AI, how it will take us all over, as if it hasn’t already. As though the very process of writing this isn’t repeatedly interrupted by red underlines telling me I’m making a mistake, and now, because I got a free upgrade, blue lines suggesting what a better sentence would be. I mostly ignore these, for the record, because when I quoted Toni Morrison in a previous piece, the blue line offered improvements for her, too.
Listen.
I don’t know much about most things, particularly about artificial intelligence. But even a dummy like me can see that it’s only a matter of degrees, takeover-wise. Our pot is nearly boiling; the water has been warm for a while.
August and April.
A total solar eclipse in 2017. I view it from my building’s rooftop in lower Manhattan through a jerry-rigged Fruit Loops box a neighbor shared with me. The slow and then sudden daytime darkness is—in the dictionary definition of the word—awesome. Another one happened early last Spring. I watch it with scores of New Yorkers at the Brooklyn Botanical Gardens. The gathering of souls sprawled across swaths of green tucked in from the city’s rough edges by not-yet-blossomed cherry trees is strangely intimate and lovely despite the celestial event itself being less dramatic than the one seven years ago.
It doesn’t matter.
On both occasions, I am more transfixed by the people around me, looking up, than what’s happening in the sky.
This is partly how I’m built. Hypervigilant. Tracking the condition of everyone in each moment, whether or not they seem okay. It’s a problem a lot of the time, but like most maladaptations, there are benefits, too. A sensitivity to rhythms, a discernment for patterns. A perception of energetic shifts in ways others might miss. Clocking the collective pulse.
In the hours surrounding both eclipses, it felt definitive. Out of one thing and into something else. A down-regulation. Peaceful, steady, and pure. I experience it viscerally, but it’s visible in the expressions of everyone around me, as well. To a person, regardless of apparent race or apparent age — all are attuned. Calm. Reverent.
In some ineffable way, I’ve tried but can’t completely describe in a single word except to say:
Human.
Out of curiosity, following the April eclipse, I prompt Dall-E to create variations of human beings looking toward the sky in awe. I try a woman, a man, a child, a family, a crowd. I try an older woman and then an older man because I like to be representative in my research. I change ‘in awe’ to ‘with reverie.’ I try ‘with a slight smile.’
No
is what I think in response.
You don’t get it yet.
—
With zero warning before changing how it works, Google now answers any question one asks with an AI-generated response. That seems an odd choice for a system still being trained, one that may still be dangerous. After reading about Sora, I ask Google if the sky is, in fact, limitless.
No is the answer the robots give me, followed by a few bullet points indicating why. One of these introduces me to the Kármán line, the generally agreed-upon point at which our atmosphere ends and space begins. It’s the place where conventional aircraft can no longer effectively fly. The thing I discover about this line, though, the further down the Google hole I go, past the intelligence identified as artificial, is that experts disagree on where precisely a distinct boundary lies. Meaning the limits of the sky are based on a combination of known physical reality and human construct. Or, like every system put in place to keep society quasi-functional, the sense of reality we ascribe.
—
The flood of identical text blocks purporting to opt out of Meta’s use of personal data to train their A.I. that arrived across Instagram stories a little while back, cause me to physically wince. Compassion for the instinct to do it, pity knowing that posting anything on a digital platform is not a legitimate way to deny monolithic tech Gods’ permission. A couple of months earlier, someone put a 14-step instruction guide on Facebook for how to opt out of training the Zuckerbots.
I’m a person who spent the last decade and a half posting their writing and photography on these platforms, so the idea of my work being lifted and fed into the mouth of an anonymous machine I do not even begin to comprehend is at once terrifying and enraging. I don’t know how to describe realizing this was already occurring without my agreement other than as a psychic violation. So, I followed the 14 steps, which were purposefully confusing and took a very long time. A few weeks later, I got an email from Meta effectively stating that in the United States, no laws exist to make opting out an actual…option.
I have unchecked every box I can find anywhere on God’s green Internet to say no, anyway. No, you may not use my pictures or words to train your machines. Because this is mine. NO. You can’t just trawl me with a digital net, scooping up the way I see the world, how I take what I’ve found and then shape it and hone it and carefully give it to the people I love or believe care enough to bother looking through my lens. But then I think: What’s the use? There will be robots. There already are. You are only reading this thanks to robots. Chips and transistors, 0s and 1s. Or something like that.
I told you at the beginning I don’t understand any of it, not really, at all.
—
The chilly night I was with my old friends in the compassionate low lights of a warm Brooklyn restaurant when the flashes of electric color swam through our phones was, as it turned out, the occasion of a geomagnetic storm. The Aurora Borealis, or the Northern Lights, which I’m ashamed to admit I didn’t realize was an event that could be witnessed except in places like Norway or Alaska. It occurs when electrons from the sun interact with the Earth's magnetic field and collide with molecules in the atmosphere. According to my robots, the storm originated from a solar flare that erupted (quite specifically) out of Sunspot 3842 and was the strongest recorded in the past seven years.
—
I become obsessed with the text prompts humans have entered to make Sora create for them.
A beautiful silhouette animation shows a wolf howling at the moon, feeling lonely, until it finds its pack.
A young man in his 20s is sitting on a piece of cloud in the sky, reading a book.
A petri dish with a bamboo forest growing within it that has tiny red pandas running around
Photorealistic closeup video of two pirate ships battling each other as they sail inside a cup of coffee.
A flock of paper airplanes flutters through a dense jungle, weaving around trees as if they were migrating birds.
New York City submerged like Atlantis. Fish, whales, sea turtles and sharks swim through the streets of New York.
Extreme close up of a 24 year old woman’s eye blinking, standing in Marrakech during magic hour
A cartoon kangaroo disco dances
I want to know why you need a machine to make you a bird. I want to know if it matters which book the young man is reading on his cloud. I want to know why you picture pirates doing battle in your coffee and who’s the captain now. I want you to tell someone with a heartbeat about the lonely wolf in your imagination howling at the moon.
—
Tuesday, November 5th.
If you’ve made it this far, maybe you want me to say what the heavens and the robots, the text prompts, and human faces all have to do with what happens in America on Tuesday. I’m going to tell you right now.
We’re still working to understand the systems’ dangers. Artificial systems, yes, but in my personal opinion? Every system. All of them.
I want a leader who knows which limits are worth pushing past and for what reasons. I want a President who, when she talks to a person, looks them in the eye, holds their hands, and allows them space if they’re frightened or grieving and begin to cry; I want a President who instinctively connects, who doesn’t need text prompts spelled out with a Sharpie to be capable of asking teenaged mass shooting survivors what can we do to help you feel safe or to come up with I hear you in response to their reply.
I want, we all need, a person in charge who is human in a way that’s not fully articulable in words but which is equally impossible to deny.
—
Now.
I’ve been trying to explain something about reality: our capacity for perceiving it, our ability to know the difference between what’s true and what isn’t, our instincts and intuition for either or both, which are not necessarily the same. I’m trying to tell you something about art and creation, about wondering and beauty, and about looking up at the sky. I’m trying to say something about making machines do things for us, things we might need to keep doing ourselves for humans to actually survive.
I worry I’m not doing a good enough job.
I want you to see every moment on this harrowing and exquisite orb spun out of darkness and stardust borne from chaos and constant miracles is a cartoon kangaroo disco dancing if you look closely enough.
This is exactly what I needed to read right now. You are a beacon of light and love. Xoxo
Thank you for this astonishing piece.